Monday, October 3, 2011

"A Film Unfinished" Response


“A Film Unfinished”, otherwise known as “Das Ghetto”, is an excellent example of how history can be falsified by those who want to cover up their sickening crimes, for which they feel no shame. The question must be asked, what would have happened if the film had been completed and released at that time, earlier, or later.
Would we have believed the Nazis lies and accepted their hatred for others? The propagandists’ manipulation of their half-million prisoners was clear, by showing numerous outtakes of the same ‘scene’, posing and re-posing the Jews to fit perfectly into their twisted film. The film crew posed somewhat well-dressed Jewish women by a restaurant and ignoring the children that begged for food; to show the supposed callousness by the ‘wealthy’ Jews. To indicate that the Jews were treated well, living in simply a ‘secluded paradise’, yet they were cruel towards those who had less. Showing that the Nazis were being ‘charitable’, even to such ‘cruel’ people as the Jews. The out and out lies are utterly disgusting. During the film, it cuts back and forth to a movie theater showing a few Jewish people observing. Near the end of “A Film Unfinished”, we see the bodies of small children, the tiny feet. One woman observing the film says “I am human now, now I can cry”, she hides her face repeatedly from the screen, afraid of the heartbreaking horror. Throughout cutting back to the observers, we hear comments such as “When did you ever see a flower? We would have eaten a flower!”
The fact that the Nazis created such ridiculous lies, expecting others to believe their film, indicates again that the Nazis viewed any other human as a lesser being, just varying extents of their levels of disgust towards them. As we watch the Jews in the streets being filmed, their sunken cheeks and darkened eyes, one cannot help but receive chills. The people who had their lives, their dignity and self-respect stolen, still held onto their faith, and hope. As you watch the people in the streets eye the cameramen, it seems that there is no emotion through their eyes, only numbness. The survivors reflect on losing their families, everything being ripped away from them. It is horrifying and hard to watch an entire group of people steadily destroyed, but it is also necessary to do so. If we forget even for a second how we must hold together our fellow humans, we have lost more than we can even imagine.

7 comments:

Devan McCallister said...

I agree the disregard to human life that was displayed was sickening.

Ian "Panda" Ehrhart said...

Disregard for human life is common when your own existence is on the line. From personal experience I can tell you (and obviously my situation wasn't even a fraction as bad as theirs) that when your life is empty and cold, you have no room to feel for others because you don't even have the room to feel for yourself. In a situation like this you have no room for emotion for anyone.

sherilstephens said...

It's really crazy to think that so many people can be manipulated to do such horrendous things. When the lady said she was human again and could cry that broke my heart. I have tried to understand how the Germans being in a depression of their own before Hitler, and on the brinks of starvation and so on could allow others regardless of religion, skin color, whatever the case to suffer as they just had. I just don't get it....

Justin Middleton said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Justin Middleton said...

I completely agree with your analysis. It is so twisted what was done to these people. What is really sad is the filming for propaganda to gain sympathy from others.

billyessick said...

i totally agree with your resonse, it was a tummy twister watching that survivor watch this film and to see her facial exspressions, she was there first hand

Mr. Neuburger said...

I find your question about how would the film been received had it been finished. I wonder what it would have looked d like. It certainly would have been much shorter.